Use of Cassava as Animal Feed

http://www.mekarn.org/procKK/wana3.htm

Role of cassava hay as animal feed in the tropics 

M Wanapat 

Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture,
Khon Kaen University, Khon Kaen 40002, Thailand 

Abstract 

Cassava (Manihot esculenta Crantz), an annual tropical tuber crop, was nutritionally evaluated as a foliage for ruminants, especially dairy cattle. Cultivation of cassava biomass to produce hay is based on a first harvest of the foliage at three months after planting, followed every two months thereafter until one year. Inter-cropping of leguminous fodder as food-feed between rows of cassava, such as Leucaena leucocephala or cowpea (Vigna unculata), enriches soil fertility and provides additional fodder. Cassava hay contain 20 to 25% crude protein in the dry matter, and with very minimal HCN content.  

Feeding trials with cattle revealed high levels of DM intake (3.2% of BW) and high DM digestibility (71%). The hay contains tannin-protein complexes which could act as rumen by-pass protein for digestion in the small intestine. Therefore, supplementation with cassava hay at 1-2 kg/hd/d to dairy cattle could markedly reduce concentrate requirements, and increase milk yield and composition. Moreover, cassava hay supplementation  in dairy cattle could increase milk thiocyanate which could possibly enhance milk quality and milk storage, especially in small  holder-dairy farming. Condensed tannins contained in cassava hay have also been shown to potentially reduce gastrointestinal nematodes and therefore could act as an anthelmintic agent. Cassava hay is therefore an excellent multi-nutrient source for animals, especially  for dairy cattle during the long dry season, and has the potential to increase the productivity and profitability of sustainable livestock production systems in the tropics. 

Key words: Cassava hay, livestock, multi-nutrient, feed, tropics
 

Introduction

Cassava or tapioca (Manihot esculenta ,Crantz) is an annual tuber crop grown widely in tropical and sub-tropical areas. It thrives in sandy-loam soils with low organic matter, and in areas receiving low rainfall and with high temperatures. It is therefore a cash crop cultivated by small-holder farmers within the existing farming systems in many countries. Cassava tubers contain high levels of energy and minimal levels of crude protein, and have been used as readily fermentable energy in ruminant rations. Cassava  leaves have been used as a protein source when collected at tuber harvesting time. However, the intake and digestibility was low due to the high level of condensed tannins (Reed et al 1982;  Onwuka 1992). Harvesting of cassava at an early growth stage (3 months) to make hay reduces the condensed tannin content and increases the protein content (to 25% of DM) resulting in a higher nutritive value (Wanapat et al 1977).
 

Planting, cutting and cultivation for hay making 

Studies by Wanapat et al (1997,2000a, 2000b, 2000c, 2000d) have revealed the details of planting cassava and making hay. Planting cassava for hay is aimed at increasing the whole crop digestible biomass, with the tuber root as a by-product. Earlier work by Wanapat et al (1997) demonstrated that  planting cassava at 60x40 cm between rows and inter-cropping with cowpea or leucaena could enrich soil fertility and the legumes could be used as food and feed for humans and livestock, respectively. The initial cutting was at 3 months, and was followed by subsequent cutting at every two months by breaking of the stem about 10 cm above the ground. The fresh  whole crop was directly sun-dried or chopped before sun-drying to obtain a dry matter level of 80-90%. This might take 2-3 days, but chopping helps shorten the drying process. Sun-drying also eliminated more than 90% of the hydro-cyanic acid (HCN) and enhanced the palatability and long-term storage. Intercropping cassava with leguminous crops such as cowpea could improve soil fertility and provide food for human consumption, while the residue could be used as supplemental feed, especially during the dry season (Polthanee et al. 2001). Planting space and frequent cutting have been shown to affect the combined yield of the cassava hay (Petlum et al 2001). Furthermore, planting pattern, either with non-ridging or ridging, as well as manure fertilization affects cassava hay production (Puangchompoo et al 2001).
           

Cassava hay as a source of protein and condensed tannins 

It has been found that cassava hay harvested at an early stage of growth (3 months) contained up to 25% crude protein, and with a good profile of amino acids. Digestibility and intake studies in cattle resulted in relatively high values, which demonstrated that cassava hay was palatable and digestible. Condensed tannins (CT) were generally found in higher concentrations in matured cassava leaf,  but levels were lower in cassava hay harvested at a younger stage. Barry and Manley (1984) and Reed (1995) reported that if condensed tannins in the feed exceeded 6% of dry matter, feed intake and digestibility would be reduced. If the CT level was between 2-4% DM it would help to protect protein from rumen digestion, thereby increasing by-pass protein. 

Cassava hay contains condensed tannins(CT) or proanthocyanidins (PC),  which are common in tropical plants. CT are polyphenolics which can easily be solubilized in water and can precipitate protein. The presence of condensed tannins and protein can result in the formation of tannin-protein complexes (TPC) by hydrogen-bonding, especially under alkaline pH conditions. TPC will maintain its complex at pH 3.5-7.0, and will dissociate under pH<3.0 and >8.0 (Jones and Mangan 1977). Condensed tannins have been found to increase N-recycling in the rumen and saliva (Reed 1995) and moreover to improve rumen microbial protein synthesis (Makkar 1995). However,  McSweeney et al (2000) found reduced rumen cellulolytic bacteria in sheep fed tannin-containing diets, although microbial protein synthesis was not affected.  The mode of action of CT on rumen fermentation is yet to be elucidated  

Effect of residual hydro-cyanic acid (HCN) as thiocyanate in cassava hay as milk preservative 

As has been reported by Claesson (1994), milk thiocyanate is required in the lactoperoxidase system in milk to help increase the shelf-life, although the optimal level of milk thiocyanate should not exceed 20 ppm.  Dairy cows fed with cassava hay as a supplement, have been shown to have a milk thiocyanate content of 19.5 ppm. However, more research is needed in order to pin-point the role of residual HCN in cassava on milk thiocyanate.  

Effect of condensed tannins as a gastrointestinal  anthelmintic agent 

Gastrointestinal (GI) parasites or nematodes have been found widely in the tropics, and result in poor performance of ruminants. Common GI nematodes found include Trichostrongylus colubriformis, Ostertagia circumcincta, Haemonchus centortus and T. vitrinus. Animals infected with these nematodes exhibited higher requirements for protein and minerals due to the loss of endogenous nitrogen (blood, plasma, mucin and sloughed cells) and lowered P adsorption (Poppi et al 1985; Kahn and Diaz-Hernandez 2000). Preliminary work by Netpana et al (2001) showed that the fecal parasitic egg counts in cattle and buffaloes were significantly lower when fed with cassava hay that contained condensed tannins (CT), and were similar to the group that had been drenched. Possible explanations are that the animals received supplemental protein and /or that CT could have a direct effect on the internal parasites. Possible mechanisms through which CT may reduce larval migration and development remain to be elucidated, but the effect may be mediated through ingestion of CT and interactions of CT with the external surface of the larvae ( Kahn and Diaz-Hernandez 2000). 

Feeding trials using cassava hay (CH) 

Cassava hay has been used successfully as a source of high protein roughage for lactating dairy cows (Wanapat et al 2000a; Wanapat et al 2000b). Wanapat et al (2000a)(Table 1) found that increasing levels of CH from 0.6 to 1.7 kg/hd/d reduced concentrate use from 0.1 to 1.6 kg/hd/d, respectively, without affecting milk yield. Moreover, feeding CH ad libitum gave a similar result and could further reduce concentrate use. 

Table 1. Effects of cassava hay (CH) supplementation levels on ruminal pH, NH3-N, milk yield and milk composition in late lactating cows fed urea-treated rice  straw (UTRS) as a roughage

CH replacement of  urea-treated straw

CH0

CH8

CH15

CH18

CH100

SEM

Cassava hay DM intake, kg/d

-

0.56

1.13

1.70

5.2

0.20

Condensed tannin intake, g/d

0

1.44

2.90

4.37

13.36

5.26

Concentrate saving, kg/d

-

0.10

1.30

1.60

3.1

-

Urea-treated rice straw, kg DM/d

6.8

6.4

6.7

8.0

-

0.28

Ruminal pH

7.2

7.0

7.0

7.0

6.8

0.13

Ruminal NH3-N, mg/100 ml

17

13

13

16

7.0

0.52

Milk yield, kg/d

6.3

6.1

5.4

6.1

5.4

0.24

3.5% FCM,kg/d

6.8ac

6.2ab

6.0b

7.1c

6.4ab

0.13

Milk  fat, %

4.0a

3.6b

4.2a

4.5c

4.6c

0.11

Milk protein, %

4.4a

4.0a

3.8a

4.1a

5.3b

0.17

Solids-not-fat, %

8.6

8.8

8.4

8.6

8.4

0.12

Total solids, %

12.6

12.3

12.0

12.2

12.6

0.18

abc Values on the same row with different superscripts differ (P<0.05).CH0= Urea-treated rice straw (UTRS0 ad lib.+ Conc: Milk yield(1:2) + 0 CH; CH8= UTRS ad lib. + Conc: Milk (1:2)+ CH at 0.56 kg DM/hd/d. CH15= UTRS ad lib. + Conc: Milk (1:3)+ CH at 1.13 kg DM/hd/d.; CH18= UTRS ad lib. + Conc: Milk (1:2)+ CH at 1.70 kg DM/hd/d.; CH100= Cassava hay ad lib. + Cassava root (cassava chip + 3% urea ) at 2 kg/d.

Studies  were conducted to examine the effect of supplementation level of cassava hay (CH) in dairy cows. Six multiparous Holstein-Friesian crossbreds were paired and randomly assigned in a change-over design to receive three levels of CH supplement , at 0, 0.8 and 1.7 kg DM/hd/d. Concentrate was supplemented at the same level (1:2, concentrate:milk yield) while urea-treated (5%) rice straw was offered on an ad libitum basis. The results revealed that  supplementation of CH significantly reduced concentrate use, without affecting milk yield (12.5, 12.12 and 12.6 kg/hd/d) and significantly improved 3.5% FCM (14.21, 15.70 14.9 kg/d, respectively). Moreover, CH supplementation significantly increased milk fat and milk protein percentages, especially at 1.70 kg/hd/d. Concentrate use was reduced by 27% at 1.7 kg/hd/d CH supplementation. 

Table 2.  Effect of level of chopped cassava hay on milk yield and composition of  Holstein-Friesian crossbreds fed urea-treated (5%) rice straw ad libitum

   

Chopped cassava hay , kg/d

SEM

 

0

0.8

1.70

 

Concentrate DM Intake, kg/d

5.53

5.00

4.03

0.25

Concentrate saving, kg (% of control)

0

0.53 (10)

1.50 (27)

0.30

Milk yield, kg/d

12.5

12.1

12.6

0.57

3.5% FCM, kg/d

14.2a

15.7c

14.9b

0.67

Milk composition

 

 

 

 

    Fat, %

4.06a

4.15a

4.61b

0.19

    Protein, %

3.40a

3.34b

3.50c

0.08

    Lactose, %

4.64a

4.82b

4.62a

0.05

    Solids-not-fat, %

8.74

8.80

8.81

0.09

    Total solids %

13.5

13.1

13.7

0.32

a,b,c, Values with different superscripts differ (p<0.05); Wanapat et al (2000a)

In a later experiment (Wanapat et al  2000b), supplementation of cassava hay to replace concentrate use was studied in lactating Holstein Friesian crossbreds grazed on Ruzi grass. Six multiparous cows in  mid-lactation were paired and randomly assigned according to a change-over-design to receive three combinations of cassava hay and concentrates (Table 3).  

Table 3.  Effect of cassava hay (CH) supplementation on concentrate use and milk yield and composition

Conc : Milk ratio  

1:2

1:3

1:4

SEM

CH supplement,  kg DM/d

0

2.85

4.02

 

Concentrate DM Intake, kg/d

4.56a

3.20b

2.64c

0.25

Concentrate saving, kg (% of control)

0

1.36(30)

1.92(42)

-

Milk yield, kg/d

10.7

10.1

10.4

0.58

 3.5% FCM, kg/d

12.6

12.5

12.6

0.75

Milk composition

 

 

 

 

    Fat, %

4.61a

4.98 b

4.80ab

0.13

    Protein, %

3.36a

3.60b

3.45ab

0.10

    Lactose, %

4.47a

4.66b

4.53

0.07

    Solids-not-fat, %

8.80a

8.95b

8.68c

0.09

    Total solids

13.41

13.54

13.50

0.24

    Thiocyanate, ppm

5.3a

13.3b

17.8b

0.77

abc Values with different superscripts differ (P<.05). Wanapat et al (2000 a)

 Milk yields were similar among treatments, while protein, lactose and solids-not-fat percentages were highest (P<0.05) in cows receiving CH at 1.0 kg/hd/d. The most significant improvement from CH supplementation was that it allowed a reduction in concentrate use of 42%, which would  provide a higher income for small-holder dairy farmers (Table 4).  

Table 4.  Effect of cassava hay supplementation on economical returns 

Conc : Milk  

1:2

1:3

1:4

CH suppl, kg DM/d

0

2.85

4.02

3.5% FCM, kg/d

12.6

12.5

12.6

Milk sales, Baht

141

140

141

Concentrate intake, kg/d

5.15

3.62

2.97

Concentrate cost, Baht/d

60.9

21.7

17.8

Cassava hay intake, kg/d

0

2.85

4.02

Cassava hay cost, Baht/d

0

1.92

2.01

Total feed cost

30.9

23.6

19.8

Income over feed: 

Baht/hd/d

1

116

121

Baht/hd/month

3,324

3,494

3,652

$US

92.3

97.1

101

1 kg milk = 11.20 Baht, kg conc = 6.00 Baht, kg Cassava hay = 0.50 Baht.; 36 Baht = 1 $US
Wanapat et al (2000 a)

 In addition, milk thiocyanate was increased from 5.3 in the control group to 17.8 ppm (P<0.05) in the CH supplemented group (1.7 kg/hd/d). These results are in line with the work of Woodward et al (1999), who reported that dairy cows fed with Lotus corniculatus, which contained condensed tannins, had a 42% improvement in milk yield and 57% increase in milk protein percentage, without changing feed intake.  

A participation scheme involving small holder dairy farmers in improving dairy production through the use of local feeds, on-farm established feeds and crop residues, was carried out in Northeast, Thailand. At six milk collection centers, 63 farmers with 340 lactating cows participated in this study and demonstration of feed supplements.  Farmers and cows were allotted to receive the following respective feed supplements: High-quality feed block (HQFB); high-quality feed pellet (HQFP), dried cassava leaf/cassava hay, dried lecuaena leaf and cottonseed meal. Rice straw treated with 5% urea was fed as a source of roughage throughout the feeding period of the dry season. Training courses and workshops were organized by the researchers at the University, research station, demonstration sites and on-farms. Regular visits to the farms by researchers and extension officers were made, and in addition regular discussions and demonstrations were held. Participating farmers also visited other farmers during the demonstrations, which offered a real practical perspective and farmer-to-farmer interaction. As a result of this participation and demonstration scheme, the farmers could learn more effectively and accepted the technology more readily, especially the practical details of the feed preparation, feed establishment, feeding method and feed  preservation.  

Strategic supplementation of these feed supplements resulted in improved milk yield, milk quality, overall condition of the cows and higher economic returns through increased productivity and lower ratios of concentrate to milk yield, from  1:2 to 1:3 or lower. Based on this research and demonstration/participation scheme, all feed supplements were shown to enhance productivity. However, the establishment of cassava hay on farms requires more attention and warrants a wider expansion among dairy farmers, since it could be easily produced and be sustainable on farms (Wanapat et al 2000c) (Table 5).  

Table 5. Effect of local feed supplements on milk yield and composition of lactating dairy cows*, conducted as on an on-farm trial

 

 

HQFB

HQFP

DCL

DLL

CSM

 

 

P

D

P

D

P

D

P

D

P

D

Milk yield, kg/d

9.80 +2.9

10.4+2.78

11.05 +3.21

12.0+4.55

9.08 +2.16

10.1+2.53

9.76 +1.78

10.7 +2.1

11.7+2.80

13.0 +3.10

 

3.5% FCM,kg/d

10.75+1.80

11.9+2.10

11.9 +2.80

13.9 +2.25

10.2+2.30

11.7+2.40

10.5+2.15

12.3 +2.90

10.9+2.65

12.6 +3.40

 

Fat, %

4.1

4.4

4.0

4.2

4.3

4.5

4.0

4.4

3.05

4.20

 

Protein, %

3.3

3.4

3.2

3.3

3.2

3.3

3.2

3.3

3.20

3.30

 

Lactose, %

5.1

5.1

5.0

5.0

5.0

5.0

5.1

5.0

4.90

5.00

 

SNF, %

9.1

9.2

8.8

9.0

8.8

9.0

9.0

9.0

8.85

8.90

 

TS, %

13.2

13.4

12.8

12.8

13.1

13.3

13.0

1.3.4

11.90

12.65

 

* Three farms within each group, 30 farms in all, with similar conditions were randomly selected. P = pre-trial; HQFB = high-quality feed block;  D= during trial, HQFB= High-quality feed pellet; DCL = dried cassava leaf/hay  DLL=  dried leucaena leaf; CSM= cottonseed meal. Wanapat et al  (2000c)

 

On-going research and devopment work with small-holder dairy farmers using cassava hay as an intervention           

As an on-going  research activity with small-holder dairy farmers, the effect of planting cassava inter-cropped with cowpea to produce hay has been investigated. Four groups of farmers, 4 farms each, were randomly allotted to the following interventions: no cassava; with cassava; cassava inter-cropped with cowpea and cassava inter-cropped with leucaena. Feed biomass  will be collected and measured for the yield and nutritive values. Cassava hay will be collected throughout the year. Cost of production and net profit, and on-farm input-output relations will be analyzed (Wanapat et al 2001).

Conclusions and recommendations 


References

Barry  T N  and Manley T R    1984  The role of condensed tannins in the nutritional value of  Lotus peduculatus for sheep 2. Ouantitative digestion of carbohydrates and protein. Br. J. Nutr. 51:493.

Brooker  J D., O’Donovan  L ,  Skene I and Sellick  G  2000  Mechanisms of tannin resistance and detoxification in the rumen. In. Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed.J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp.

Claesson  O  1994  The use of the lactoperoxidase system. In:Proc. Regional Workshop on Raw Milk Handling and Preservation in the Near East Region. FAO, Rome , Italy.

Jones  W T  and Mangan  J L  1977  Complexes of the condensed tannins of sanfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia) with fraction 1 leaf protein and with submaxillary mucoprotein and their reversal by polyethylene glycol and pH. J.Sci. Food Agric. 28:126.

Kahn  L P and  Diaz-Hernandez  A  2000  Tannins with anthelmintic properties. In Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed.J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp. 

Makkar  H P S  2000  Evaluation and enhancement of feeding value of tanniniferous feeds. In: Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp. 

McSweeney  C S.,  Palmer B and  Krause  D O 2000  Rumen microbial ecology and physiology in sheep and goats feel a tannin-containing diet. In: Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp.

Netpana  N., Wanapat M and Toburan  W 2001  Effect of cassava hay supplementation on internal parasitic egg counts in swamp buffalo and cattle. In: Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp. 

Norton  B W  2000  The significance of tannins in tropical animal production. In: Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nutrition (Ed J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proceedings No.92. 171pp.

Onwuka  C F I  1992  Tannin and saponin contents of some tropical browse species fed to goats. Trop Agric (Trinidad) 69:176.

Petlum  A., Wanapat M and  Wanapat  S  2001  Effect of planting space and cutting frequency on cassava hay yield and chemical composition. In:Proc. International workshop on Current research and development of cassava as animal feed, organized by Khon Kaen University and the Mekong Basin Animal Research Network (MEKARN), July 23-24, Kosa Hotel, Khon Kaen, Thailand.  

Poppi  D P., MacRae  J C ,  Brewer  A ,  Dewey P J S and  Walker  A  1985  Calcium and phosphorus absorption in lambs exposed to  Trichostrongylus colubriformis. J. Comp. Pathology. 95:453-464.

 Polthanee  A., Wanapat  S,  Wanapat M and  Wachirapakorn  C  2001  In: Proceedings of an International Workshop on Current research and development of cassava as animal feed, organized by Khon Kaen University and the Mekong Basin Animal Research Network (MEKARN), July 23-24, Kosa Hotel, Khon Kaen, Thailand.

Puangchompoo  A., Wanapat  S, Pothanee  A ,  Wachirapakorn C and  Wanapat  M 2001  Effect of planting methods, fertilization on cassava hay yield and chemical compositions. In: Proc.  International Workshop on Current research and development of cassava as animal feed, organized by Khon Kaen University and the Mekong Basin Animal Research Network (MEKARN), July 23-24, Kosa Hotel, Khon Kaen, Thailand.

Reed J D 1995  Nutritional toxicology of tannins and related polyphenols in forage legumes. J. Anim. Sci. 73:1516.

Reed J.D,  McDowell  R E,  Van Soest P J and  Horvath  P J 1982  Condensed tannins, a factor limiting the use of cassava forage. J. Sci. Food Agric. 33:2131.

Wanapat M., Pimpa  O ,  Petlum A and Boontao  U  1997  Cassava hay: A new  strategic feed for ruminants during the dry season. Livestock Research for Rural Development, 9(2):  http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd/lrrd9/2/metha92.htm.

Wanapat  M.,  Petlum A and Pimpa  O  2000a   Supplementation of cassava hay to replace concentrate use in lactating Holstein Friesian crossbreds. Asian-Australasian J. Anim. Sci., 13:600-604.

 Wanapat  M.,  Puramongkon T and  Siphuak  W  2000b  Feeding of cassava hay for lactating dairy cows. Asian-Australasian J. Anim. Sci., 13:478-482.

Wanapat  M.,  Pimpa  O ,  Petlum   A ,  Wachirapakorn  C and  Yuangklang  C  2000c  Participation scheme of smallholder dairy farmers in NE Thailand on improving feeding systems. Asian-Australasian J. Anim. Sci., 13:830-836.

Wanapat  M., Pimpa  O ,  Sripuek W,  Puramongkol  T ,  Petlum  A , Boontao U,  Wachirapakorn C and Sommart  K  2000d  Cassava hay: an important on-farm feed for ruminants  In Proc. International Workshop on Tannins in Livestock and Human Nurition (Ed J D  Brooker), ACIAR Proc. No. 92, p. 71-74.

Wanapat  M.,  Polthanee  A ,  Wachirapakorn  C ,  Anekwit T and Mattarat  S  2001  Crop-animal systems research network (CASREN). Progress Report-Thailand, ILRI  Paper,20 pp.

Woodward  S L, Auldist M J, Laboyrie  P J, Janse E B L and Cottle D  1999  Effect of Lotus corniculatus and condensed tannins on milk yield and composition of dairy cows. Proc. of N.Z. Society of Animal Production, p. 152-155.

Go to top