Recycling  organic  wastes  to  produce  earthworms as a protein supplement in diets for poultry and fish

Bui Xuan Men, Brian Ogle^* and T R Preston^**

College of Agriculture and Applied Biology,
Cantho University, Vietnam,
 bxmen@ctu.edu.vn

^*Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Sweden

^**UTA-TOSOLY, Colombia

Abstract

A series of trials were conducted in 2006 and 2007 on a smallholder farm in Omon district in Cantho City in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam to evaluate the use of animal wastes for the production of earthworms (Perionyx excavatus) and the effect of using these as protein supplements in diets of growing crossbred ducks and freshwater turtles (Trionyx sinensis), and using the vermicompost for planting water spinach (Ipomoea aquatica).

The experiment on producing earth worms included four treatments with four replicates. The worms were supplied with different wastes: (1) fresh cattle manure (FCM); (2) a mixture of cattle manure and composted cattle manure (MCM), (3) composted cattle manure (CCM), and (4) a mixture of fresh water hyacinth and pig manure after being kept together for one week (HPM). These wastes were offered to the worms once every five days. The biomass gains of the fresh worms after 60 days were: 962, 12, 476 and 1772 g per square meter, and the waste conversion ratios (kg DM/kg fresh worms) were: 14, 2630, 58 and 8 for FCM, MCM, CCM and HPM, respectively.

In the second experiment ducks from 14 to 60 days of age were fed the worms as part or complete replacement for a protein supplement in the diet. There were three treatments with four replicates and four ducklings per group: (1) ducklings confined and fed a commercial mash control diet (Ctr); (2) ducklings confined and fed a diet with 50% of the protein from soybean replaced by that from the fresh worms (50R) and (3) ducklings confined and fed a diet where 100% of the protein of soybean was replaced by the fresh worms (100R). Daily live weight gains were 45.8, 47.8 and 47.5 g and feed conversion ratios 3.3, 3.1 and 3.2 for the Ctr, 50R and 100R diets, respectively.

The trial on freshwater turtles that were fed the worms from 30 to 90 days old included three treatments with three replicates and two young turtles per group. The treatments were: turtles confined in buckets with swimming water and fed (1) commercial pellet control (CPC), (2) confined as (1) and fed fresh small minced fishes (FFM), and (3) confined as (1) and fed whole the live worms (WEW). The final live weights were 10.2, 11.5 and 13.1 g, and the gains were 3.2, 5.0 and 7.3 g for CPC, FFM and WEW, respectively.

Vermicompost that remained after harvesting the worms was used to fertilize water spinach (WS) with three treatments and three replicates. The treatments were: (1) the WS fertilized with 35 g/m² of urea (CtrU), (2) the WS with 25 kg/m² of vermicompost (VCP), and (3) the WS with (2) plus 20% urea of (1) (UCP). After 25 days, biomass yields of the WS were 0.33, 0.29 and 0.42 kg/m², and after a 15 day growth, the biomass of the second cut was: 0.92, 0.86 and 1.10 kg/m² for CtrU, VCP and UCP, respectively.

Use of animal wastes to produce earthworms and vermicompost to raise ducks, turtles and water spinach is a way to increase outputs of farm products and decrease the use of inorganic chemicals in integrated agriculture.

Key words: Ducklings, earthworms, freshwater turtles, growth, vermicompost, wastes, water spinach.

Introduction

After the re-emerged avian influenza epidemics, poultry production has been gradually recovering on smallholdings in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam. At present (end of 2007), commercial protein feeds for livestock production are sold at so high prices that the farmers find it difficult to get any economic benefits from poultry raising. Protein feeds produced in the Delta are limited and the natural sources of these are tending to become impoverished. Also, soya beans imported for livestock are so expensive that producers can not use them for feeding their animals, especially the smallholder producers. Animal manure and other organic wastes are considered as waste materials with very low value and are little used in the Delta. It is hypothesized that they could be used as the main substrate material to raise earthworms by suitable methods for producing fresh worms that are regarded as an ideal and inexpensive protein source for feeding directly to poultry or fish all the year round. Small preliminary trials with chicks fed fly larvae recently carried out (Bui Xuan Men et al 2005) partly confirmed this. A study in Colombia on producing earthworms to feed poultry has shown interesting results (Rodríguez et al 1995).

In order to solve the problems above,  a series of trials were conducted in 2006 and 2007 on a smallholding in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam to evaluate the use of animal wastes for the production of earthworms (Red worm, Perionyx excavatus) and the effect of using these as protein supplements in diets of growing crossbred ducks and freshwater turtles (Trionyx sinensis), and vermicompost for planting water spinach (Impoea aquatica).

Use of animal wastes to produce earthworms and vermicompost to raise ducks, turtles and vegetables is a way to increase outputs of farm products and decrease the use of inorganic chemicals in agriculture and thus reduce pollution from animal production activities in the Delta.

Materials and methods  

Experiment 1: Use of  animal wastes to produce earthworms (Red worms, Perionyx excavatus) 

Experimental design:

The experiment was carried out on a smallholding in the agricultural suburban area of  Cantho City in the Mekong Delta. The trial was a completely randomized design, with four treatments and four replicates. The treatments were:

• Worms offered fresh cattle manure (FCM)

• Worms offered a mixture of cattle manure and composted cattle manure (MCM)

• Worms offered composted cattle manure (CCM)

• Worms offered a mixture of fresh water hyacinth and pig manure (ratio 1:1) one week after mixing (HPM).

The wastes were prepared and supplied to the worms once every five days throughout the experiment. The worms were kept in 30 cm deep holes with walls of bricks, placed in a house with a thatched roof that prevented direct sunlight reaching them (Photo 7). The temperature in the house averaged 26.9-27.8⁰ C, and relative humidity averaged 72-82% before and after watering. A dense black nylon net covered the surfaces of the holes to reduce the light reaching the worms. All the holes were watered from a pond adjoining the canal with an amount of 2-5 liters daily to maintain the relative humidity in the holes at 70-80%.

Initially, the holes were filled with a ground basal mixture of decayed rice straw and vermicompost. Layers of the different wastes were put in the holes, alternating with the basal mixture, and then the worms were placed. Finally the black nets were placed over the worm holes.  Observations were made daily to check the development of the worms. When vermicompost, excreted from the worms, emerged on the surface new wastes were added, around  five days. Parameters measured were biomass and growth index of the worms, waste conversion ratios, nutrient composition and carbon ratios of the wastes: % C = (100-% ash)/1.8 (Adam (1951), cited by Tran Thi Thuy Hang (2007)).

Experiment 2: Use of earthworms as a part or complete replacement for a protein supplement in diets for broiler ducks.

There were three treatments with four replicates and four ducklings per group. The treatments were:

• Ducklings confined and fed a commercial mash control diet (Ctr)

• Ducklings confined and fed a diet in which 50% of the protein of soybean was replaced by that from the fresh worms (50R)

• Ducklings confined and fed a diet in which 100% of the protein of soybean was replaced by that from the fresh worms (100R).

These diets were supplied to the ducks ad libitum three times per day.

The ducks were housed in a shed divided into pens. The pens were made from bamboo frames, with thatched roofs and brick floors covered with rice straw or dried grass for bedding, and with an average density of one duck per 0.25 m². The ducks also had access to outside covered sand yards with an area of 1 m² per duck. The temperature in the house averaged 25.5⁰C and relative humidity averaged 71.5% in the morning (8:00h), 28.8⁰C, 73.2% at noon (12:00h), and 25.3⁰C and 84.2% at night (22:00h). Natural light was used in the day time, with light from electric bulbs at night with an intensity of 3W/ m² to maintain a total of 24 hours light each day. 

Feeders used were round plastic basins 30 cm in diameter and 10 cm deep. Drinkers were round plastic containers linked to a plate so that water was filled automatically. In addition, a round plastic basin 60 cm in diameter was put in the end of each pen and filled intermittently with water to meet both the drinking and bathing requirements. Both feeders and bathing basins were cleaned daily in the morning.

During the brooding stage up to 14 days of age the ducklings were fed mash ad libitum and then fed the experimental grower diets. The feed was formulated and produced from feedstuffs purchased in a local feed shop, with the composition shown in Table 1.

Parameters measured included nutrient composition of the diets, growth rate of the ducks, feed conversion ratios, carcass traits, investment and net economic benefits from the ducks.

Experiment 3: Use of live worms as the sole feed for freshwater turtles

The trial included three treatments with three replicates and two young turtles per group. The treatments were:

• Turtles confined with swimming water and fed commercial pellets, control (CPC)

• Turtles confined as in (1) and fed fresh small minced fish (FFM)

• Turtles confined as in (1) and fed whole live worms (WEW)

Two young freshwater turtles were kept in each bucket (25 x 25 x 40 cm height). The buckets were two thirds filled with fresh water together with some water hyacinth plants and some hollow bricks. 

Comercial pellets, fresh small minced fish and live worms were supplied once daily to the turtles in CPC, FFM and WEW, respectively.

Parameters measured were live weights of the young turtles at 30 and 60 days and feed conversion ratios over the 60 day period of the experiment.

Experiment 4: Use of excreta from worms (vermicompost) for growing water spinach

The trial consisted of three treatments with three replicates. Each replicate was water spinach (WS) planted on a 1 m² area. The treatments were:

• WS fertilized with 35 g/m² of urea (CtrU)

• WS fertilized with 25 kg/m² of vermicompost (VCP)

• WS fertilized as in (VCP) plus 20% urea as in (CtrU) (UCP)

In treatments VCP and UCP, 10 kg of the vermicompost was mixed with the soil one day before seeding the WS. The amount of WS seeds placed on the soil surface in all treatments was 10 g/m². After seeding, the first fertilization was carried out when the plant had 4 true leaves, then once every 5 days, and fertilization stopped 10 days before harvesting.

Parameters measured were the heights of WS from the row surface to the highest leaf tops and total biomass (leaves and stems) of the WS after 25 days for the first harvest and 15 days after the first cut for the second harvest.

Chemical analyses

Samples of wastes, worms, vermicompost and feeds for ducks were analysed for dry matter, organic matter, nitrogen, crude fibre, ether extract, nitrogen free extract, ash and amino acids by standard AOAC methods (AOAC 2000).

Statistical analyses

The data were analyses by analysis of variance using the General Linear Model procedure in the ANOVA  program of MINITAB statistical software, version 13.2 (Minitab 2000).

Economic analyses

Economic analyses were carried out using current prices in Vietnamese Dong (15,900 VND=1US$) to compare the feeding costs and feed cost per live weight gain among the different treatments.

Results and discussion

Experiment 1: Evaluation of different wastes for producing red worms

Chemical composition of wastes

The chemical composition (DM basis) of the wastes is shown in Table 1. The organic matter (OM) content of the fresh cattle manure was highest (77.9%) and the lowest OM was for the composted cattle manure (64.1%). However, the OM data of fresh cattle manure in the trial is lower than the data reported by Edwards and Niederer  (1998), but is similar to the value of 78.5% reported by Thieu Hoang Duy (2004).

The total nitrogen concentration in the mixture of fresh pig manure and water hyacinth was highest, with the lowest value for the composted cattle manure. The nitrogen concentration in the fresh cattle manure was rather low, only 1.37%, and the resulting a C/N ratio thus was rather high (31.7), which is higher than the value reported by Le Van Can (1982) of 20-25. Nguyen Duy Quynh Tram (2004) reported that the chemical composition of animal manures is very variable, and depends on factors such as the feed given, processing of the manures, and the time and conditions for storage.

The values of OM, nitrogen and C/N ratio in the composted cattle manure were rather low, probably because the materials were composted for a long time (5 to 6 months) and as a result there would have been some decomposition by the microbes in the manure.

Worms can survive at pH from 4 to 9 ( Nguyen Thi Hue Thanh, 2002), but most earthworms reproduce and grow best at a pH of around 7. Thus the mixture of hyacinth and pig manure (HPM) would have been the most suitable. Water hyacinth is readily available in the Mekong Delta, and is used for feeding ducks (Bui Xuan Men et al 2005 and pigs (Nguyen Ba Trung 2003), and was also used efficiently in this trial.

Earthworms can develop and reproduce at temperatures of 25 – 30⁰ C (Nguyen Van Bay 2004), but the optimum is around 25⁰ C (Edwards and Niederer 1998). During the 8 weeks of the experiment the temperatures fluctuated from 26.9 to 27.8⁰ C (Figure 1), which were slightly higher than the optimum.

Worms (Perionyx excavatus) are rather sensitive to changes in the relative humidity (RH), which influences their development (Nguyen Van Bay 2004). The optimum RH for worms is around 75.2 – 83.2% (Hallatt 1992). Figure 2 shows the effects of treatment and watering on RH.  

Biomass yield and growth coefficients of the worms were highest on the mixture of water hyacinth and fresh pig manure;  values for the worms grown on the composted cattle manure were lowest. It seems that the worms grew best on HPM due to its higher content of nitrogen and organic matter, while composted cattle manure cannot be recommended. The waste conversion rate was best for the HFM and worst for the CCM treatment.

The OM content was highest in FCM, while the nitrogen content was highest in HPM (Table 4).

Experiment 2: Evaluation of whole worms for feeding ducks

The fresh worms used as replacement for soybean meal had an average DM content of 21.5% (Table 5). . The protein content (64.5% of DM) was higher than that found in the study reported by Nguyen Duy Quynh Tram (2004).  The crude protein content in all diets was kept constant at 16.0% in DM. However, the amounts as fed in the 50R and 100R treatments were higher than of the control treatment because fresh worms replaced soybean meal (Table 6).

There no significant differences between treatments for growth rate, feed intake and feed conversion of the ducks given earth worms as partial or total replacement of the soybean meal (Table 7).  

 

The lowest feed cost per kg live weight gain was for the 100R diet, in which the protein supplement was completely replaced by fresh worms. There would thus appear to be marked economic benefits to the producers using fresh worms produced on farm by household labour.

Experiment 3: Live worms for growing freshwater turtles

After two months of the trial the turtles fed with the live worms tended (P=0.093) to have the highest live weight gains, with the lowest gains for the turtles fed the commercial feed pellets. Duong Nhat Long et al (1999) reported that the growth of young turtles is very slow and the gains are dependent on environmental conditions, such as temperature, weather and diet quality. The growth results of  the turtles at the end of the trial (three months of age) are similar to the study of Nguyen Duy Khoat (1999), who reported that young turtles at 6 months of age have live weights around 15 to 20 g.

     Experiment 4: Vermicompost as a growth medium for water spinach

The data in Table 10 tend to support the finding of Pham Thanh Binh (2002) that a combination of chemical fertilizer and compost to fertilize water spinach results in higher biomass yield than when these inputs are supplied singly. Overall yields were lower than reported by Bui Van Cong (2004), because the water spinach was planted out of season, in colder than normal weather.

 

Conclusions

·        Pig manure mixed together with water hyacinth stored for one week and fresh cattle manure are good substrates for production of earthworms

·        Earthworms can completely replace soybean meal in diets for growing ducklings

·        Freshwater turtles had higher growth rates when fed in earthworms compared with minced fish or commercial feed.

·         There appear to be advantages for combining chemical fertilizer with vermicompost for growth of water spinach

·         Use of animal wastes to produce earthworms and vermicompost to raise ducks, turtles and water spinach is a way to increase outputs of farm products and decrease the use of inorganic chemicals in integrated agriculture.

 References

AOAC  2000  Official methods of analysis  Association of Official Analytical Chemists,

Washington, DC

Bui Xuan Men, Ogle B and Preston T R  2005: Production and evaluation of Black Soldier fly larvae and termites as protein supplements for chickens.  Workshop-seminar "Making better  use of local feed resources" (Editors: Reg Preston and Brian Ogle) MEKARN-CTU, Cantho, 23-25 May, 2005. Article #24. RetrievedJuly 23, 108, from http://www.mekarn.org/proctu/ba24.htm

Duong Nhat Long and Pham Thanh Liem  1999  Techniques for raising amphibians and  reptiles. Lecture notes,  Cantho University.

Edwards C A and Niederer A 1988 The production and processing of earthworm protein. In: Edwards, C A, Neuhauser E F. (Editors.), Earthworms in waste and environmental management. Academic Publishing, The Hague, The Netherlands, pp. 169-180.

Hallatt  1992  Moisture requirements in the life cycleof Perionyx excavatus (Oligocheata). Soil-Biol-Biochem. Volume 24(12), pp 1333-1340

Le Van Can  1982  Organic fertilizer. Agricultural Publishing House, Hanoi.

Minitab  2000  Release 13.20 for Windows, Mintab Inc. USA.

Nguyen Ba Trung  2003  Evaluation of  yields and use of  water hyacinth in diets of fattening pigs. MSc. Thesis. Cantho University.

Nguyen Duy Khoat  1999  Techniques for raising freshwater turtles, field frogs and crossbred catfish. Agricultural Publishing House, Hanoi.

Nguyen Duy Quynh Tram, Le Duc Ngoan and Ogle B  2005  Culturing earthworms on pig manure and the effect of replacing trash fish by earthworms on the growth performance of Catfish (Clarias macrocephalus x Clarias gariepinus). http://www.mekarn/msc2003-05/theses05/tram_p2.pdf

Nguyen Thanh Binh  2000  Influences of inorganic and organic nitrogen on performance and accumulation of nitrate in sweet cabbage in Summer-Winter crop 2000 in Cantho. Report of Cantho University.

Nguyen Thi Hue Thanh  2002  Techniques for raising earthworms intensively. Report for training extension of agriculture in Cantho City.

Nguyen Van Bay  2004  Guide-techniques for raising earthworms. Agricultural Publishing House, Ho Chi Minh City.  

Rodríguez Lylian, Salazar Patricia and Fernanda Arango María 1995 Lombriz roja californiana y azolla-anabaena como sustituto de la proteina convencional en dietas para pollos de engorde.  Livestock Research for Rural Development (8) 3 http://www.cipav.org.co/lrrd/lrrd7/3/5.htm

Thieu Hoang Duy  2004  Treatment of fresh cattle manure by an aerobic method. MSc. Thesis. Cantho University.

Tran Thị Thuy Hang  2007  Use of organic wastes to produce red worms for feeding farm animals. Report of Cantho University.

Go to top